When it comes to lipsticks, we usually fall into two camps:
- Those who love bold pigments and long stay (drugstore classics).
- Those who crave comfort and care (but often sacrifice color payoff).
I thought I knew which side I was on—until I put Mamaearth Lipstick to the test for a week. The results genuinely surprised me, and they might change how you look at lipsticks too.
Why I Decided to Test Mamaearth Lipstick
The beauty industry is evolving. Today’s consumers are asking for more than just color; they want:
- Safer, toxin-free formulas
- Hydration and comfort for everyday wear
- Products that align with clean beauty principles
Mamaearth claims to deliver all three. But could it really compete with a tried-and-tested drugstore favorite?
The One-Week Lipstick Experiment
To find out, I wore:
- Mamaearth Lipstick for the first half of the week
- My regular drugstore lipstick (Maybelline/Lakme) for the second half
I judged them based on five key factors: pigmentation, longevity, comfort, ingredients, and value.
Mamaearth vs Drugstore Lipstick: Head-to-Head
| Category | Mamaearth Lipstick | Drugstore Lipstick | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pigmentation | Buildable, natural finish (needs 2 coats) | Intense color in one swipe | Drugstore |
| Longevity | Lasts 5–6 hours, fades after meals | Lasts 7–8 hours, stronger hold | Drugstore |
| Comfort | Lightweight, hydrating, lips stay soft | Can feel heavy and drying over time | Mamaearth |
| Ingredients | Made Safe certified, no parabens, enriched with oils | Contains parabens and synthetic waxes | Mamaearth |
| Value | Mid-range clean beauty pricing | Often more affordable | Depends on preference |
The Surprise Factor
I expected Mamaearth to feel like a tinted balm—pleasant but not long-lasting. Instead, it performed like a proper lipstick while keeping my lips comfortable.
By Day 4, my lips felt less dry than usual. That was a big shift from the typical post-lipstick dryness I face with drugstore brands.
A Quick Look at the Ingredients
Mamaearth emphasizes skin-friendly formulations, and this lipstick reflects that:
- Avocado Oil → locks in moisture, prevents flakiness
- Vitamin E → provides antioxidant protection
- Natural Waxes → give structure without synthetic chemicals
- No Parabens or Mineral Oils → safer for long-term use
Drugstore alternatives often use synthetic waxes and parabens for performance, which work for color payoff but can feel harsh on sensitive lips.
The Shades You’ll Find
Mamaearth Lipstick is available in a versatile palette designed for Indian skin tones. Popular choices include:
- Nude Nuance – a perfect everyday office shade
- Rose Pink – soft feminine look for casual wear
- Classic Red – bold and confident evening shade
- Wine Berry – rich tone for festive occasions
The shade range might not be as extensive as some global brands, but it covers the most wearable and in-demand colors.
Who Should Choose Which?
Mamaearth Lipstick is better for you if:
- You have dry or sensitive lips
- You value clean, toxin-free beauty
- You prefer a natural, buildable finish
Drugstore lipsticks may suit you better if:
- You want bold pigment in one swipe
- You need all-day wear without reapplication
- You’re on a strict budget
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1. Does Mamaearth Lipstick dry out lips?
No. Thanks to Avocado Oil and Vitamin E, it keeps lips nourished.
Q2. How long does it last?
On average, 5–6 hours. Touch-ups are needed after meals.
Q3. Is it safe for sensitive lips?
Yes, it’s dermatologically tested and free from harmful chemicals.
Q4. Does it transfer?
Slightly, like most creamy lipsticks, but not excessively.
Q5. How many shades are available?
It comes in a wide range, from subtle nudes to bold reds.
Final Verdict – Did Mamaearth Win Me Over?
While drugstore lipsticks still lead in boldness and staying power, Mamaearth surprised me with its comfort and safer formulation. For everyday use, it feels like a healthier choice that doesn’t punish your lips. 💄✨
If you wear lipstick daily, the difference in hydration and ingredient safety is worth considering.
Why You Can Trust This Review
- Trustworthiness: Balanced review—highlighting both strengths and weaknesses.
- Experience: Personally tested both lipsticks for a full week.
- Expertise: Evaluated across industry-standard criteria.
- Authoritativeness: Comparison supported by ingredient research and real usage.
💬 Want more expert skincare and beauty insights? Explore our latest tips, reviews, and guides at Dhawan Suits – Skincare & Beauty.
About the Author
Tanvir Kaur is a passionate fashion and lifestyle blogger who brings a curated blend of festive fashion, everyday style, skincare wisdom, and lifestyle inspiration directly to your feed. From runway-inspired looks to simple beauty hacks, she makes style accessible, inspiring, and real. Her content helps readers feel confident and stylish every day.
